What actually is the best choice for wastewater collection?

On Nov. 20 a local newspaper printed a headline that caught my attention.

Dear editor,

On Nov. 20 a local newspaper printed a headline that caught my attention. Peg Sloan of Westerose appears to laud the need for a connected low-pressure wastewater system on the south shore of Pigeon lake.

The headline is in error, as the proposed low-pressure wastewater system is not as safe as current systems of septic tanks on individual lots, when both systems are properly managed.

In fact, if health is the issue, septic tanks are slightly safer than low-pressure or grinder systems as verified by scientific study. The headline writer will leave many readers with the opposite impression. A low-pressure waste system combines the use of septic tanks with communal piping and pumps. The addition of pipes, pumps, filters and settling tanks of a low-pressure communal system adds its risks to those of septic tanks alone.

The low-pressure systems still use septic tanks on individual lots and then combine a grinding and/or pumping service to transfer the effluent into the community plumbing pipes. In a summer village setting, which exists along the entire south shore of Pigeon Lake, additional risks are associated with the communal pipes that do not exist with tanks alone. About 80 per cent of summer village residents use their property as summer cabins or homes. Mechanical and hydraulic problems are at significant risk in winter as no one is present to attend to them. In addition, when the pipes are not kept full and flowing, the low flow through the plumbing lines increases the risk of blockage, leakage and hence increases the risk of soil contamination. The soil contamination risk may even be significant in summer due to electrical and mechanical engineering problems and pump filter maintenance. It is sad that the problems associated with this pattern of usage are not being offered to ratepayers by those councils that are pushing for the low-pressure communal systems.

Associated with these extra risks are extra costs being transferred to the lot owners themselves. Problems can and will develop in installing the pumping systems within each septic tank currently in use. Further, partial use of the street plumbing will require valve closure and opening patterns when the communal system is not in use. Failure to respect this important feature will risk backflow from the communal system into the individual lot, with expensive problems in the individual lots that suffer regurgitant effluent. This problem is most likely, as 80 per cent of the lots have no full-time residents who will be available to turn off and on their connections whenever there is a community problem with the street pipes, putting their local system at risk.

There is much more to know. A group known as the “Lakewise” team has been distributing information, where these important details are revealed, comparing individual lot with communal sewer systems in such vital areas as costs, health and other issues of importance to every lot owner. These include risks of septic tank damage, repairing STEP and grinding systems and issues involved within the community pipes and pumping that cause problems with individual lot systems. With these issues in mind, any concerned lot owner can find on the internet reports where low-pressure systems are being replaced and existing systems are being replaced, and existing systems being disallowed in small communities. Check out “low-pressure wastewater” management to get started.

So, it is sad the newspaper in question has, by its headline, given readers the idea that low-pressure communal waste collection is the way to go. For both safety and cost, individual septic tanks remain a healthier and less expensive way to handle wastewater at this time in the Summer Village of Pigeon Lake.

Reg Roberts, Edmonton

(Also Pigeon Lake area resident)

 

Just Posted

Field scouting in July

Field scouting can lead to more successful crop production

Wind, wet lodging crops in fields

By Ponoka News Staff The rain may help with moisture concerns but… Continue reading

Alder Flats 4-H Multi Club Report

4-H kids visited aerial park in Edmonton

Mexican recipes for Dora’s Kitchen this week

Tasty enchilada recipe has two types of chilies

Wetaskiwin RCMP investigate indecent act at By The Lake Park

Complaint said man exposed himself in Wetaskiwin

Fashion Fridays: 5 casual summer dress styles

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Bashaw seed cleaning plant holds official opening

New facility operating well since January

Couple found dead along northern B.C. highway in double homicide

Woman from the U.S. and man from Australia found dead near Liard Hot Springs

Bank of Canada lowers qualifying rate used in mortgage stress tests

Home sales softened last year after the federal government introduced new stress test rules for uninsured mortgages

$900M settlement reached in class action on sexual misconduct in Canadian military

After facing criticism, the government moved to begin settlement proceedings in early 2018

Chiefs honour Indigenous leader wrongfully hanged in B.C. 154 years ago today

Chief Joe Alphonse says they want his remains returned to his homeland in B.C.’s Cariboo region

Scrapie, a disease related to mad cow, found in two flocks of sheep in Alberta

Health Canada says there is no known link between scrapie and human health

Alberta oil and gas producer cleanup cost estimates set too low, says coalition

Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. facing the largest bill at $11.9 billion to clean up 73,000 wells

Scheer on Trump: It’s ‘offensive’ to question the family background of critics

Trump is being called a racist for saying that the four congresswomen should go back where they came from

Most Read